James E. Cordes, James M. Walker
Copeia 2006 (1), 14-26, (1 February 2006) https://doi.org/10.1643/0045-8511(2006)006[0014:EASIOS]2.0.CO;2
The whiptail lizard Aspidoscelis dixoni (Teiidae) comprises three distinctive color pattern classes (i.e., variants); A and B are restricted to Presidio County, Texas, and C is isolated over 500 km to the west-northwest in Hidalgo County, New Mexico. Pattern class E of A. tesselata is widely distributed in Chihuahua, Texas, and New Mexico. Genetic data have verified that these parthenogenetic species are hybrid-derivatives of A. tigris marmorata ♀ X A. gularis septemvittata ♂; however, the number of hybridization events involved in their origin has remained problematic. We used 19 lizards in laboratory skin-grafting experiments to test the histoincompatibility responses among A. dixoni A, B, C, and A. tesselata E. The results of these graft exchanges indicated that individuals of all four pattern classes were mutually histocompatible to skin grafts, a level of genetic homogeneity indicative of the origin of A. dixoni and A. tesselata from the same hybrid lizard. Thus, the color pattern variants A. dixoni A, B, C, and A. tesselata E are identifiable products of mutation and/or recombination in a single historical group. Such postformational genetic changes have not been shown to be capable of mimicking the mutual graft rejection responses that occur between all members of historical groups derived from different hybrid zygotes. Falsification of the hypothesis that A. dixoni and A. tesselata were derived from different hybrid individuals also nullified the generally accepted rationale for their treatment as separate species. Aspidoscelis dixoni is revealed to consist of a morphologically well-defined grouping of three of the several diploid color pattern classes (i.e., tokogenetic arrays) in the A. tesselata complex that are also potentially diagnosable as species using similar criteria. Based on histocompatibility data presented herein for the A. tesselata complex and a review of preexisting data for other taxa, we provide a comparison of published opinions pertaining to the taxonomic status of A. dixoni and A. tesselata and the other named parthenogenetic entities in the A. cozumela, A. sexlineata, and A. tesselata species groups of Aspidoscelis. This generic name was recently resurrected from the synonymy of Cnemidophorus; however, monophyly has yet to be achieved for the revised genus “Cnemidophorus” owing to paraphyly in the “C. lemniscatus” species group.
La lagartija cola de látigo Aspidoscelis dixoni (Teiidae) comprende tres clases distintivas de patrones de coloración (esto es, variantes); las clases A y B están restringidas al condado de Presidio, Texas, y la C está aislada a más de 500 km hacia el oeste-noroeste en el condado de Hidalgo, Nuevo Mexico. La clase E de A. tesselata está ampliamente distribuida en Chihuahua, Texas y Nuevo Mexico. Datos genéticos han verificado que estas especies partenogenéticas son derivadas de híbridos de ♀ de A. tigris marmorata y ♂ de A. gularis septemvittata; sin embargo, el núm